For some reason it seems Simon Cowell, judge of American Idol so it says, has decided to
have a go a Bob Dylan.
No Rock 'n' Roll Fun have had a go at this and it's probably only a matter of time before
Ten-Bob Dylan has a go, even the Guardian article get's in the required cheap shot:
"Of course, who could dispute the musical gravitas of the man behind such talents as Robson and Jerome, and Il Divo, versus that of one of the defining icons of the last century?"
But it seems to me that Cowell is right, in a way. Bob probably does bore him to tears, that's just a matter of taste I don't think Dylan will be losing any sleep over that.Cowell also says, though:
"I've got to tell you, if I had 10 Dylans in the final of American Idol, we would not be getting 30 million viewers a week. I don't believe the Bob Dylans of this world would make American Idol a better show."
The first point is almost undeniably true. If 10 Dylans are in the final, a Dylan is going to win, so why watch it? Perhaps if they let him do some original material instead of trying to make all those Dylans sound like the same, bland karaoke contestant that American Idol churns out (although it might be fun to watch Dylan trying to remove all the things that make him unique in order to belt out a soaring rendidtion of Wind Beneath My Wings so he can be told "he really owned that song") , then it might drag in a few viewers but even then probably not 30 million. Ratings for a show and the talent displayed on it being rarely connected.
The Bob Dylans of this world couldn't possibly make American Idol a better show, it s what it is and no amount of turd-polishing is going to help. The Bob Dylans of this world could make a better show, they could make something with integrity, talent, heart, artistry, all those things that are important to people who really like music, given the audience we have, unfortunatly, it would probably last about 5 episodes before the ratings killed it, with people turning over to watch the next great soap event instead.